Reading: A How-To Guide, Part 1: Bookmarks and Footnotes

I figured I’d share a couple of tips and tricks I use when reading as well as some philosophical subjects around reading. In this first installment, I’ll cover bookmarks and then footnotes.

I have found that boarding pass stubs make great bookmarks. Well, at least back in the day when accounting didn’t require you to send them in after your trip to prove you didn’t just hitchhike to Shanghai and sell your airplane tickets on eBay or something. I had a period of relatively heavy travel where I accumulated a stack about 2 inches tall of stubs. I found initially that on the airplane of course, they were useful when I started a new book during the trip. I gradually got around to using them all the time. The beauty is that I had lots of them so I could (obsessively?) mark lots of interesting places in books. For example, my current page, the end of the current chapter, the middle of the book and the end of the book. If I got even more anxious, I’d add one at the end of additional sections or chapters. This was of course a challenge with Proust where the chapters were about 150-200 pages long so that’s when I used the “every 100 pages” trick or perhaps the “every 50 pages” trick. I suppose it gave me a goal and thus subtle encouragement to keep going. Also, since I had loads of them, I could make pages in several books at the same time if I was doing some parallel reading. The last benefit of this technique was that I was reminded of the trips (particularly the fun ones) whenever I looked at the stubs.

The other subject I wanted to mention was footnotes. I have had mixed opinions of footnotes and figured I’d share them with my readers. As I see it, there are two ways that authors use footnotes and at least two philosophies for readings of books with footnotes. Either the author leaves the actual note at the bottom of the page or s/he collects them into a Notes section at the end of the book. The reader’s challenge is then whether to read each footnote as s/he comes to them or let a certain number go by and catch up at the end of a chapter. The first writer/reader techniques mentioned go rather well together as well as the second writer/reader technique. The hard bit is when you are reading something really dense like, say, Joyce’s Ulysses or the aforementioned Proust where the footnotes are copious and relegated to the end of the book. An annoying amount of time is spent going back and forth from the text to the notes. And yet, one has a hard time picking up on the sense of the text and the context without the notes. I always tried to take the middle road and try to get through a paragraph before flipping back but sometimes this was cumbersome when there were pages and pages of notes. Another strategy would be to read ahead in the notes. But in that case, I’d usually forget what the point was when I was back in the text and have to go back hunting again in the notes. Needless to say, it is singularly unrewarding unless you are passionate about the book in question. The last book I reviewed about Einstein only had bibliographical references so I never actually looked back at the notes. So there it is: does one read in a staccato fashion bouncing back and forth from text to notes or does one just forge through and try to go back through the notes on the second read. I wonder what your strategies are…

Actually, the last time I read Ulysses about two years ago, I started by first reading three literary criticisms and Ellmann’s biography and then the actual text. I found I could get through 5-10 pages before needing to peruse the notes which were more of a reminder than a guide in this case. For Proust, I read Painter’s and Tadie’s biographies as well as about 4 literary criticisms but still had to often go to the notes to get contextual data. So, I suppose your mileage varies. On the other extreme, my American Library copies of Faulkner have no notes at all. Now, it is a bit frustrating to have no notes but I did go and read the two-volume Blotner biography of Faulkner for background on him and had the world’s greatest English teacher in high school where we studied Light in August and As I Lay Dying so I suppose I used those inspirations and my southern upbringing as guidelines where none were given in the book.

About these ads

About Michael Finocchiaro

IT Architecture Guru for large PLM software company but dabbling in Web 2.0 and other stuff.
This entry was posted in books, reading and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Reading: A How-To Guide, Part 1: Bookmarks and Footnotes

  1. Emma says:

    Ah yes, the problem of footnotes is so tiresome! I seem to lose concentration when flicking to the back of a book, but texts like Arden’s Shakespeare that put all the footnotes on the featured page make it appear rather cluttered. Shame that there is not another way. Also, I wrote my dissertation on Faulkner so feel your pain; he is slightly confusing at times! Though I suppose that’s part of the charm.

    • mfinocchiaro says:

      Thanks for the comment and the subscription :)
      Actually, I found Faulkner really depends on which period of his writing we are talking about. His later books seem to me to be easier to follow. Of course, it helps to have a pocket map of Yoknapatawpha County and a Burden/Sartoris/Bayard family tree handy :)

  2. i.heart.hk says:

    Am I correct to assume, that you could be an “enemy” of e-book readers? ;-)

    In September of last year, I became a fan – a dedicated fan of e-book readers. Both problems that you touch in your blog, are solved very nicely in my reader (won’t leave the brand name, don’t want to be accused of spamming).

    Bookmarks – basically, there are several types. For starters, your typical bookmark to show you where you left off. It turns on automatically, when you turn off the reader, or when you leave the book (e.g. to read another book, or to check something online). Another type, is marking your favorite quotes. No more scribbling on pages, no more post-it notes, no more bent page corners. What’s more, you can share that bookmark with others, as well as see how many people liked the fragment that you did.

    Footnotes – in my reader they will be placed at the end of the book (or chapter), but they will be hyperlinked – one click to read the footnote, once click to get back to reading. You can practically do it with one hand, so reading on a bus, when you have to hold on to something, became much easier.

    There’s plenty of other things, in which the reader is – in my opinion at least – much better than a book… Ever tried?

    • mfinocchiaro says:

      To be honest, I haven’t really given e-book readers beyond the iPhone or iPod a chance yet. The iPhone is obviously too small so disqualified. I have been rather disappointed by the iPad as an e-reader – as you advance through a book, the image of the hidden pages both to the left and right doesn’t change so you don’t get the impression that you are moving forward. I suppose the other thing is the tactile feel of the pages and the relative weight in your hands is critical for me. I can see your points about using social media with bookmarks and such but I haven’t really done that yet. Does that make me a luddite? Perhaps it does. I have heard great things about the Kindle though – the latest generation that is. Is that the one you are using?
      Sounds like for footnotes in any case that the e-book carries a big advantage!

      • i.heart.hk says:

        Yes, I’m using a Kindle (latest gen., but only WiFi, no 3G) and it’s a completely different experience, than an iPhone or an iPad.
        Weight – practically like a bigger paperback. With an iPad (I don’t own one, useless for me) my hands got tired after about 15 minutes. Kindle you can hold in one hand.
        Capacity – I have about 120 books on mine (and space for about a thousand more?), about 8 hours of music on mp3, a number of pdfs with maps, city plans etc. Your luggage gets significantly lighter when traveling, and it’s really hard to run out of books. Not to mention, then you can buy new ones within seconds.
        Progress -well, the only way to do it, was to place a progress bar at the bottom of the page; works fine for me.
        The only down side of it, is that you can’t read it when it’s dark (the only advantage of mobile phones and tablets as readers, by my count) – but then again it’s the same with books.
        For me, Kindle (probably other branded readers, too) have another advantage over books – a Cambridge dictionary of English. Being that I’m not a native speaker of English, it comes in handy very often :-)

        If you get a chance to try an e-book reader, e.g. if some of your friends have it, give it a shot. Could be worth it.

        Oh, and sorry if I sound like Amazon sales – I just really love my Kindle! ;-)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s