Music Review: I’m With You: Refried Chili Peppers for Sale

Blood Sugar Sex Magik

When I think back to 1991, as I did yesterday, and I recall albums from that time (notably Nevermind and Metallica), there was also the advent of Blood Sugar Sex Magik. While not the revolution that Nevermind, it burst the Chilis into the mainstream kind of like the Metallica album did for them. It was the ultimate party album at the time. One just needed to throw on Suck My Kiss and the house was rocking and everyone was dancing. But, in the years since BSSM, things for the Chilis have radically changed. They broke away a bit from their formula with One Hot Minute as they catered to Dave Navarro’s replacing Frusciante but, at least for me, all the material since has been based almost entirely on the BSSM format. I can’t stand Californication as an album (Scar Tissue being a decent ballad but not as good as Under The Bridge), or By The Way (the title track being OK but not as good as Give It Away). The few cuts I heard from Stadium Arcadium did not peek my interest at all. And now comes I’m With You. I tried to listen to it. I really did. But, it just sounds like the same refried Chilis on Californication and By The Way. There are the pseudo rock tunes and the chili ballads but gone is any snarling Frasciante guitar (I could barely hear his replacement Josh Klinghoffer in the mix at all) and without that, there is seemingly just Flea and the ego otherwise known as Keidis. It was even mildly depressing because I found myself wondering if I got old or they just got lazy…it reminded me of a concert I saw with them as headliners here in Paris about 5 years ago. They were really flat and, believe it or not, Kiedis forgot an entire chorus on Under The Bridge. Perhaps it is more healthy for me to just recall the wonderful path the Chilis took to get to BSSM (the ecstatic, funky eponymous first album with Police Buckle Down and True Men Don’t Kill Coyotes, the kick-ass followup Freaky Styley with end-to-end greatness, and the epitaph for Hillel Slovak, their first guitarist, Uplift Mofo Party Plan with the Special Secret Song Inside…). Perhaps Mother’s Milk was a warning that they might water it down but with BSSM, I thought that they could hold their edge. Well, what can I say, I wish I had been right.


About mfinocchiaro

IT Architecture Guru for large PLM software company but dabbling in Web 2.0 and other stuff.
This entry was posted in Music and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Music Review: I’m With You: Refried Chili Peppers for Sale

  1. Jon says:

    Couple of comments … I think you are underselling the RHCPs since BSSM. For me, I enjoy Californication, Scar Tissue, Can’t Stop, and Tell Me Baby just as much as the BSSM and Mother’s Milk hits. Of course, I seldom listen to records in their entirety any longer and have not botten a complete album since the iPod came out. So, I am just comparing singles versus albums in their entirety. Secondly, read Keidis’ autobiography. It is a really great read. Given what a train wreck his high school years were, it is kind of amazing he has stayed in one piece all of these years.

  2. mfinocchiaro says:

    Thanks Jon. Thing is that for me BSSM was an ALBUM and not just a string of hits. That’s why I put it in a completely different category from everything that came later. I blogged about the album vs tracks back here: a few years back. Hmm, perhaps the Keidis auto could be good but it is a bit backed up behind DFK’s Infinite Jest, Klosterman IV, the Richards auto and a few others that are lingering on my reading list…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s